The overarching goal of this site is to question the often giddy, utopianism that accompanies our journey into this new, digital-age reality. I have proposed on a few occasions that battles over issues like copyright are really just proxy wars in a larger, ideological (even semi-religious) cold war between humanistic and techno-centric values. Behind the overt defenses of online piracy or child pornography; behind the barrage of criticisms of old institutions; behind the idol worship of the concept open, there are new-age philosophers whose world views are anti-human, anti-intellectual, and anti-individual.
In this excellent, wry article for NewStatesman.com, Steven Poole offers a realist’s glimpse into the minds behind the memes. Read article here.
I laughed, I cried. Brilliant journalism.
Thanks for the recommendation David, a scathing but unfortunately mostly accurate portrayal of the situation. The only thing I took issue with was labelling all TED content as vacuous filler – baby & bathwater?
Thanks, Glenn. It’s fair to say baby & bathwater when labeling all TED content as meaningless. Certainly, plenty of smart people with interesting ideas have graced those stages. That said, I have found the TED series a little cultish myself and recommend this piece from a few years ago.
http://www.newrepublic.com/article/books-and-arts/magazine/105703/the-naked-and-the-ted-khanna?page=0,0
Cheers David, fascinating and slightly scary that these self-proclaimed seers are taken seriously simply because they can coin clever catch-phrases and sound “cutting-edge” while talking a load of absolute bollocks.
Luckily, most of the young folks I work with (in whose hands our future will hopefully be held if we don’t annihilate ourselves first) are far too sceptical and savvy to be taken in by these chicken little super-heroes.